icon Skip to content
Trigger the fancybox

Earth Eye Coal

Boldly Brown Eyeliner
Boldly Brown Eyeliner

Earth Eye Coal

0 Reviews

Description

Eye Coal is in pot form is rich and dense, a cross between a liner and a shadow. Made with cosmetic grade mineral pigment, better for you and the earth.
0.15 fl oz

*Note on new fill lines! Our new fill line reflects the size we have always had labeled on our adornments. Historically, we went above and beyond this fill but found that the product was going past its prime and suggested use of 6 months after opening. For both quality and safety, we have made this change. Please reach out if you have any additional questions!
Ritual Apply with a clean finger to the waterline of your lid, squeeze your eyes shut, then blend for that smokey gaze. For a sharp line, apply with a makeup brush. For extra staying power, use a base of powder. Shelf Life Lasts 6 months. Store in a cool and dry place. Our products are organic and freshly made-to-order skin food. We do not use toxins that make things last forever.

Ingredients

Sunflower Oil (Helianthus annuus)*, Oxide, Arrowroot Powder (Maranta arundinacea)*, Kaolin Clay, Cetyl Alcohol, Beeswax, Elderberry Extract (Sambucus)

*Organic
^Ethically & Safely Wildcrafted

Shop The Look

K
KayLa S.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
04/13/24
Everyday product for eyes and brows
Review by KayLa S. on 13 Apr 2024 review stating Everyday product for eyes and brows
I use this product almost everyday. The color is a nice nuetral brown. I use it on my eye lids as an eye liner and on my brows as well. I love it. I love the subtle look of the dark brown as opposed to the jet black... for every day use.
C
CHRISTEL D.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
05/13/23
soft chocolate brown velvety color
Review by CHRISTEL D. on 13 May 2023 review stating soft chocolate brown velvety color
This eye coal looks so natural and last throughout the day, can be applied lightly or heavier for different impact, love the soft chocolate brown velvety color!
J
Jennifer Z.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
03/01/23
Ecstacy in the Earth
Review by Jennifer Z. on 1 Mar 2023 review stating Ecstacy in the Earth
Lovely rich Earth brown color that stays in place. Really enhances my green eyes! Best of all, it feels great to know that what is going on my face is nothing but scrumptious Earth growing herbs. Thank you for this wonderful magic!
R
Rebecca B.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
09/09/22
Excellent multi-use eye makeup
Review by Rebecca B. on 9 Sep 2022 review stating Excellent multi-use eye makeup
The Eye Coal in Earth is a beautiful thing. The color works for filling eyebrows, smudging into eyelids and is safe enough to put on my waterline. It keeps my smoky eyes in place all day. Loving it.
S
Samantha M.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
07/05/22
Great product.
Review by Samantha M. on 5 Jul 2022 review stating Great product.
I was surprised by the pigmentation, but I should have known f&m would deliver the good.! I was also expecting something a little oilier but this is a quite dry/matte finish. I’m impressed by the staying power of this eye shadow. It was definitley more faint by the end of the day and a little creased. I’m very happy with this purchase.
M
Michelle F.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
03/12/22
Great low waste eyeliner!
Review by Michelle F. on 12 Mar 2022 review stating Great low waste eyeliner!
I have used this for a few days now and so far am very impressed! I use it with a slanted brow brush and it makes a great winged liner. The cream consistency is more forgiving to apply than liquid eyeliner. I expect you could smudge it out if you wanted as well, though I haven't tried. So far no running or fading problems although I haven't tried it in hot humid weather yet.
J
Jill D.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
01/11/22
Perfect
Review by Jill D. on 11 Jan 2022 review stating Perfect
I've been eying (pun intended) the brown eye coal for a while, as an alternative to more intense black eye coal. I have to say, this works wonderfully as a brow filler, as an eye shadow, and even an eyeliner. It doesn't have mega staying power (maybe setting powder would help?) as eyeliner, but a softer look (as opposed to liquid eye liner's hard lines) is what I lean towards anyways. Applies wonderfully with brushes and the color builds. Shipping was fast and everything came through just fine.

(The lip in this photo is a light application of Zlata Baba :))
K
Kay S.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
10/26/21
Earthy eyeliner and eyebrow perfection!
Review by Kay S. on 26 Oct 2021 review stating Earthy eyeliner and eyebrow perfection!
I love this eye coal! I apply with a liner brush and throw it on my brows whenever i'm in a make up mood. When I'm feeling fancy I will wear it on my eyelids. You can really layer it to make a dark pigmented eyeliner or keep it nice and light by swiping a little on by hand. The Earth color is just really nice and not too harsh, unless you layer it up. I will def repurchase when this runs out.
S
Shaina P.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
09/03/21
Fave brown kajal
Review by Shaina P. on 3 Sep 2021 review stating Fave brown kajal
Absolutely looooooove this eye coal!! I am South Asian and have grown up using kajal but always in black. The brown color is amazing and adds a kind of gentle edge to any look. It does have a tendency to run a little, so be sure to keep an eye on that but all-in-all a keeper!
G
goinggreensa
07/19/21
This fatandthemoon tint is the best thing ever. A *tiny* bit goes a long way so it’s going to last me years probably. It is so versatile and beautiful. You can use it as eyeshadow, contour, eyebrow filler and eyeliner. And it has low waste packaging. Love this thing, HIGHLY recommended!*** *****Este tinte fatandthemoon es lo mejor. Un *poquito* va mucho, así que probablemente va a durarme años. Es tan versátil y hermoso. Puedes usarlo como sombra de ojos, contorno, llenador de cejas y delineador. Y tiene un contenido bajo de residuos. Me encanta esto, esta MUY recomendado!
READ MORE...
READ LESS
U
ulu_mama_studio_
06/10/21
We are in love with fatandthemoon all natural cosmetics. They all smell magical, have no gross toxic ingredients and makes you bright, colorful, shiny and beautiful. Can you tell we are slightly obsessed? Every single product from Thai brand is herbalist formulated and hand crafted in small batches. Obsessed with them all and our shelves are restocked! Dry shampoo, pit cream deodorant, Yoni care, baby care, mouthcare, skincare and self care and self love… 🤍 . . . . #naturalcosmetics #fatandthemoon #herbalapothecary #organicskincare #handmade #selfcareproducts #selflove #lovethyself #naturalskincare #holistichealth #holisticskincare #allnatural #shopsmall #shopkauai #kauai #healthylifestyle #ulumamastudio #new #instock #supportwomeninbusiness #ohana #portal #ecoboutique #oneofakind
READ MORE...
READ LESS
K
kabukirune
12/02/20
ad pr products // Me thinking I’ve been hacked on Amazon when in fact it was just my fiancé ordering a random Christmas present for his mum. Me up all night changing passwords and cancelling cards.... 🤦🏻‍♀️ —- BASE: madaracosmetics Plant Stem Cell SPF thebodyshop Peachy Glow CC Cream 3ina The 24H Foundation ~ 601 teamrevolutionbeauty makeuprevolution Conceal & Define Concealer ~ C1 glossier Wowder ~ G11 - G12 mirenessecosmetics Blusher —- EYES: moonfat Eye Coal, Lapis, Earth we.makeup More Mascara pureanada Demure Palette —- LIPS: eyeofhoruscosmetics Bio Lip Elixir —- BROWS: muacosmetics Brow Gel ~ Dark Brown
READ MORE...
READ LESS
B
beautybybenz
09/30/20
#makeuptutorial for #hoodedeyes in my stories right now! Here’s the breakdown for the full look: prepped with soapbrows on the brows, sahajanskincare lip karma, and saintcosmetics corrector in Medium Peach. Eyes: Eye shadows: kjaerweis in Grace, Earthly Calm, and Charmed. kjaerweis eyeliner in brown, topped with moonfat eye kohl on Earth (brown). kosas Big Clean mascara. iliabeauty brow gel in medium brown. Complexion: iliabeauty Color Haze in Waking Up. kosas bronzer in Medium. exa.beauty foundation in Bensley on most of the face, with a little bit of Koko in the center of the face, blended with jennypatinkin makeup sponges. saintcosmetics corrector again in Medium Peach under the eyes. ritueldefille Rare Light Cream Luminizer in Anthelion (my all time fave). Lips: kjaerweis lip liner in Mauve topped with innbeautyproject lip glaze #2
READ MORE...
READ LESS
M
mua_megdixon
09/13/20
So I’ve been lucky enough to try a few of the moonfat makeup products... and wow oh wow! Firstly can we talk about this glow??!! I used the “𝘉𝘦𝘢𝘮” & “𝘓𝘪𝘵” glow products and boy oh boy was I shocked at the result. The glow it gives is so so natural AAAAAND the 𝘍𝘢𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘔𝘰𝘰𝘯 products are completely #natural and chemical free. Say whaaaat? That’s right. They’re cream products apply really smoothly on powders as well and look just as natural, gives such a healthy glow, AND last without disturbing or fading the makeup. Plus it doesn’t highlight skin texture 🙌🏼🙌🏼 #winning ahaha. Here I’m holding the eye coal in the shade “𝘌𝘢𝘳𝘵𝘩" which at first (as you’ll see in my makeup tutorial/review on my #youtubechannel ) I wasn’t happy with. However after giving it another go I’m actually in love with. This product is so creamy and pigmented and great to use for winged eyeliner, brow pomade AND as I’ve recently discovered... Faux freckles!!! Honestly I can’t speak more highly about this product for the #fauxfreckles effect. It applies pigmented but is so easy to blend out with the 𝘵𝘢𝘱𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘨 motion of my fingers and gives such a soft natural look. I’m such a fan of freckles so the fact that it actually gives a realistic look is EVERYTHING to me aha. What do you think? Are you a faux freckle fan? Let me know what product you love to use to apply faux freckles with? Xx . . . . . #makeupideas #makeup #makeuplook #glow #glowingskin #healthyskin #naturalbeauty #naturalmakeup #mua #instadaily #instaglam #glam #glammakeup #naturalglam #softglam #glowing #fauxfrecklesmakeup #fatandthemoon #makeuplooks #makeuplover #greenmakeup #healthymakeup #greenproducts #ecofriendly #sustainablefashion #sustainability
READ MORE...
READ LESS
M
moonfat
05/07/20
Earthy. Natural and neutral like the soil ready for planting. Earth Eye Coal is for lining lids or brows, or for creating depth by smudging a little at the edge of the eye. Wear like the Earth God/dess you are. Ps: Today is the last day to enjoy 25% our site! Photo by the Earthly Delight @hayflux
READ MORE...
READ LESS

Reviews

Reviews
Q&A

Customer Reviews

We’re looking for stars!
Let us know what you think
Description
Eye Coal is in pot form is rich and dense, a cross between a liner and a shadow. Made with cosmetic grade mineral pigment, better for you and the earth.
Ritual
Apply with a clean finger to the waterline of your lid, squeeze your eyes shut, then blend for that smokey gaze. For a sharp line, apply with a makeup brush. For extra staying power, use a base of powder.
Color Therapy
Details
A chocolatey and rich soil brown liner and shadow hybrid. Made for lovers of the classic brown and those who know the ways of natural and neutral. Wear it like the Earth God/dess you are.
Specs: 0.15 fl oz

*Note on new fill lines! Our new fill line reflects the size we have always had labeled on our adornments. Historically, we went above and beyond this fill but found that the product was going past its prime and suggested use of 6 months after opening. For both quality and safety, we have made this change. Please reach out if you have any additional questions!
Shelf Life:
Lasts 6 months. Store in a cool and dry place. Our products are organic and freshly made-to-order skin food. We do not use toxins that make things last forever.
Our Recipe
Sunflower Oil (Helianthus annuus)*, Oxide, Arrowroot Powder (Maranta arundinacea)*, Kaolin Clay, Cetyl Alcohol, Beeswax, Elderberry Extract (Sambucus)

*Organic
^Ethically & Safely Wildcrafted
Packaging is an Ingredient
Glass Jar
With Tinplate Plastisol-Lined Top
Once empty: Clean and rinse jar, separate lid, and place both parts in the recycling bin or take to your local recycling facility.

Label
Printed on 100% Post-consumer Waste material with compostable ink. They can be left on containers when placed into recycling.

Carton
Made from Post-consumer Waste Paper
Once Empty: Break down the carton and place it in the recycling bin or take it to your local recycling facility.
FAQ
Can the eye coal be used on eye brows?
A lot of customers have reported having success using Eye Coal to help fill in their brows. We suggest using a small angled brush and filling in with light strokes to avoid smudging.
I don't use this product everyday, and will soon be past the six month mark. What would happen if I keep using it past then? It seems in good condition.
Since it doesn't contain any chemical preservatives, the Eye Coal could start to dry or change consistency over time, but you can keep using it as long as it still looks and feels good to you. The best way to keep the Eye Coal good for a long time is to make sure and only use clean utensils and fingers to apply and keep the lid on to keep water and other things out!
How do you recommend removing this eye coal?
Any sort of makeup remover would of course work. We like coconut oil or a cream like All Cream to remove eye makeup.
I like applying eyeliner to my upper waterline, would this product/any of the eye coals work for this purpose?
Yes! You can apply any of the eye coals to the upper or lower waterline with a clean finger for a smudgy/smoky line or a thin brush for a more precise line.
K
KayLa S.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
04/13/24
Everyday product for eyes and brows
Review by KayLa S. on 13 Apr 2024 review stating Everyday product for eyes and brows
I use this product almost everyday. The color is a nice nuetral brown. I use it on my eye lids as an eye liner and on my brows as well. I love it. I love the subtle look of the dark brown as opposed to the jet black... for every day use.
C
CHRISTEL D.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
05/13/23
soft chocolate brown velvety color
Review by CHRISTEL D. on 13 May 2023 review stating soft chocolate brown velvety color
This eye coal looks so natural and last throughout the day, can be applied lightly or heavier for different impact, love the soft chocolate brown velvety color!
J
Jennifer Z.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
03/01/23
Ecstacy in the Earth
Review by Jennifer Z. on 1 Mar 2023 review stating Ecstacy in the Earth
Lovely rich Earth brown color that stays in place. Really enhances my green eyes! Best of all, it feels great to know that what is going on my face is nothing but scrumptious Earth growing herbs. Thank you for this wonderful magic!
R
Rebecca B.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
09/09/22
Excellent multi-use eye makeup
Review by Rebecca B. on 9 Sep 2022 review stating Excellent multi-use eye makeup
The Eye Coal in Earth is a beautiful thing. The color works for filling eyebrows, smudging into eyelids and is safe enough to put on my waterline. It keeps my smoky eyes in place all day. Loving it.
S
Samantha M.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
07/05/22
Great product.
Review by Samantha M. on 5 Jul 2022 review stating Great product.
I was surprised by the pigmentation, but I should have known f&m would deliver the good.! I was also expecting something a little oilier but this is a quite dry/matte finish. I’m impressed by the staying power of this eye shadow. It was definitley more faint by the end of the day and a little creased. I’m very happy with this purchase.
M
Michelle F.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
03/12/22
Great low waste eyeliner!
Review by Michelle F. on 12 Mar 2022 review stating Great low waste eyeliner!
I have used this for a few days now and so far am very impressed! I use it with a slanted brow brush and it makes a great winged liner. The cream consistency is more forgiving to apply than liquid eyeliner. I expect you could smudge it out if you wanted as well, though I haven't tried. So far no running or fading problems although I haven't tried it in hot humid weather yet.
J
Jill D.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
01/11/22
Perfect
Review by Jill D. on 11 Jan 2022 review stating Perfect
I've been eying (pun intended) the brown eye coal for a while, as an alternative to more intense black eye coal. I have to say, this works wonderfully as a brow filler, as an eye shadow, and even an eyeliner. It doesn't have mega staying power (maybe setting powder would help?) as eyeliner, but a softer look (as opposed to liquid eye liner's hard lines) is what I lean towards anyways. Applies wonderfully with brushes and the color builds. Shipping was fast and everything came through just fine.

(The lip in this photo is a light application of Zlata Baba :))
K
Kay S.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
10/26/21
Earthy eyeliner and eyebrow perfection!
Review by Kay S. on 26 Oct 2021 review stating Earthy eyeliner and eyebrow perfection!
I love this eye coal! I apply with a liner brush and throw it on my brows whenever i'm in a make up mood. When I'm feeling fancy I will wear it on my eyelids. You can really layer it to make a dark pigmented eyeliner or keep it nice and light by swiping a little on by hand. The Earth color is just really nice and not too harsh, unless you layer it up. I will def repurchase when this runs out.
S
Shaina P.
Verified Buyer
5.0 star rating
09/03/21
Fave brown kajal
Review by Shaina P. on 3 Sep 2021 review stating Fave brown kajal
Absolutely looooooove this eye coal!! I am South Asian and have grown up using kajal but always in black. The brown color is amazing and adds a kind of gentle edge to any look. It does have a tendency to run a little, so be sure to keep an eye on that but all-in-all a keeper!
G
goinggreensa
07/19/21
This fatandthemoon tint is the best thing ever. A *tiny* bit goes a long way so it’s going to last me years probably. It is so versatile and beautiful. You can use it as eyeshadow, contour, eyebrow filler and eyeliner. And it has low waste packaging. Love this thing, HIGHLY recommended!*** *****Este tinte fatandthemoon es lo mejor. Un *poquito* va mucho, así que probablemente va a durarme años. Es tan versátil y hermoso. Puedes usarlo como sombra de ojos, contorno, llenador de cejas y delineador. Y tiene un contenido bajo de residuos. Me encanta esto, esta MUY recomendado!
READ MORE...
READ LESS
U
ulu_mama_studio_
06/10/21
We are in love with fatandthemoon all natural cosmetics. They all smell magical, have no gross toxic ingredients and makes you bright, colorful, shiny and beautiful. Can you tell we are slightly obsessed? Every single product from Thai brand is herbalist formulated and hand crafted in small batches. Obsessed with them all and our shelves are restocked! Dry shampoo, pit cream deodorant, Yoni care, baby care, mouthcare, skincare and self care and self love… 🤍 . . . . #naturalcosmetics #fatandthemoon #herbalapothecary #organicskincare #handmade #selfcareproducts #selflove #lovethyself #naturalskincare #holistichealth #holisticskincare #allnatural #shopsmall #shopkauai #kauai #healthylifestyle #ulumamastudio #new #instock #supportwomeninbusiness #ohana #portal #ecoboutique #oneofakind
READ MORE...
READ LESS
K
kabukirune
12/02/20
ad pr products // Me thinking I’ve been hacked on Amazon when in fact it was just my fiancé ordering a random Christmas present for his mum. Me up all night changing passwords and cancelling cards.... 🤦🏻‍♀️ —- BASE: madaracosmetics Plant Stem Cell SPF thebodyshop Peachy Glow CC Cream 3ina The 24H Foundation ~ 601 teamrevolutionbeauty makeuprevolution Conceal & Define Concealer ~ C1 glossier Wowder ~ G11 - G12 mirenessecosmetics Blusher —- EYES: moonfat Eye Coal, Lapis, Earth we.makeup More Mascara pureanada Demure Palette —- LIPS: eyeofhoruscosmetics Bio Lip Elixir —- BROWS: muacosmetics Brow Gel ~ Dark Brown
READ MORE...
READ LESS
B
beautybybenz
09/30/20
#makeuptutorial for #hoodedeyes in my stories right now! Here’s the breakdown for the full look: prepped with soapbrows on the brows, sahajanskincare lip karma, and saintcosmetics corrector in Medium Peach. Eyes: Eye shadows: kjaerweis in Grace, Earthly Calm, and Charmed. kjaerweis eyeliner in brown, topped with moonfat eye kohl on Earth (brown). kosas Big Clean mascara. iliabeauty brow gel in medium brown. Complexion: iliabeauty Color Haze in Waking Up. kosas bronzer in Medium. exa.beauty foundation in Bensley on most of the face, with a little bit of Koko in the center of the face, blended with jennypatinkin makeup sponges. saintcosmetics corrector again in Medium Peach under the eyes. ritueldefille Rare Light Cream Luminizer in Anthelion (my all time fave). Lips: kjaerweis lip liner in Mauve topped with innbeautyproject lip glaze #2
READ MORE...
READ LESS
M
mua_megdixon
09/13/20
So I’ve been lucky enough to try a few of the moonfat makeup products... and wow oh wow! Firstly can we talk about this glow??!! I used the “𝘉𝘦𝘢𝘮” & “𝘓𝘪𝘵” glow products and boy oh boy was I shocked at the result. The glow it gives is so so natural AAAAAND the 𝘍𝘢𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘔𝘰𝘰𝘯 products are completely #natural and chemical free. Say whaaaat? That’s right. They’re cream products apply really smoothly on powders as well and look just as natural, gives such a healthy glow, AND last without disturbing or fading the makeup. Plus it doesn’t highlight skin texture 🙌🏼🙌🏼 #winning ahaha. Here I’m holding the eye coal in the shade “𝘌𝘢𝘳𝘵𝘩" which at first (as you’ll see in my makeup tutorial/review on my #youtubechannel ) I wasn’t happy with. However after giving it another go I’m actually in love with. This product is so creamy and pigmented and great to use for winged eyeliner, brow pomade AND as I’ve recently discovered... Faux freckles!!! Honestly I can’t speak more highly about this product for the #fauxfreckles effect. It applies pigmented but is so easy to blend out with the 𝘵𝘢𝘱𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘨 motion of my fingers and gives such a soft natural look. I’m such a fan of freckles so the fact that it actually gives a realistic look is EVERYTHING to me aha. What do you think? Are you a faux freckle fan? Let me know what product you love to use to apply faux freckles with? Xx . . . . . #makeupideas #makeup #makeuplook #glow #glowingskin #healthyskin #naturalbeauty #naturalmakeup #mua #instadaily #instaglam #glam #glammakeup #naturalglam #softglam #glowing #fauxfrecklesmakeup #fatandthemoon #makeuplooks #makeuplover #greenmakeup #healthymakeup #greenproducts #ecofriendly #sustainablefashion #sustainability
READ MORE...
READ LESS
M
moonfat
05/07/20
Earthy. Natural and neutral like the soil ready for planting. Earth Eye Coal is for lining lids or brows, or for creating depth by smudging a little at the edge of the eye. Wear like the Earth God/dess you are. Ps: Today is the last day to enjoy 25% our site! Photo by the Earthly Delight @hayflux
READ MORE...
READ LESS
Reviews
Q&A

Customer Reviews

We’re looking for stars!
Let us know what you think
The Coven
We call ourselves the ‘Coven’ as a shorthand of the space where our team gathers to intentionally conceive of, organize, create and ship out herbal bod care. We do everything under one roof, and ‘magical self manufacturing operation of botanical body care potions’ is a mouthful.
Who We Are
Herbalists, writers, proud fur baby parents, artists, musicians, gardeners, students. We self manufacture in our small town in the Sierra Foothills to invest in our incredible community of multidimensional beings.